US 401(k) proposal leaves door open to altcoins, but hurdles remain

US 401(k) proposal leaves door open to altcoins, but hurdles remain

US 401(k) Proposal: Opening Doors to Altcoins, with Hurdles

While the proposal doesn’t exclude altcoins and smaller cryptocurrencies, experts say they could face challenges getting into retirement plans. Smaller cryptocurrencies could become available in US 401(k) retirement plans under a proposed Labor Department rule, but experts suggest they may encounter more obstacles than Bitcoin (BTC) and Ether (ETH).

The rule, which reached the White House for final review on Thursday, according to the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs, aims to facilitate the inclusion of alternative investments like crypto while offering more legal protection for employers and plan managers.

The Labor Department’s March proposal lacks specifics on which digital assets can be included or a minimum market capitalization requirement. However, it provides guidelines for retirement plan managers to consider six factors when selecting investments: performance, fees, liquidity, valuation, benchmarks, and complexity.

While the proposal could potentially open doors to more cryptocurrencies in retirement plans, it doesn’t guarantee their inclusion. Smaller tokens, in particular, might face challenges due to their limited historical data, liquidity issues, and other associated risks.

Why smaller cryptocurrencies could face challenges:

Teresa Goody Guillén, managing partner at Bellementis PLLC, notes that Bitcoin and Ether are likely to be the initial cryptocurrencies offered due to their established markets and investment products. Bitcoin and Ether hold the two largest market capitalizations among cryptocurrencies, at approximately $1.5 trillion and $273 billion, respectively, according to CoinGecko data as of 20:01 UTC on Nov. 6.

However, this doesn’t automatically disqualify altcoins. Instead, plan managers must demonstrate that proposed investments meet prudence, liquidity, valuation, and investor protection standards.

“The real question isn’t which cryptocurrencies regulators pick – it’s whether an investment meets the same standards as any other retirement option,” Guillén stated. She emphasizes that while market cap is a factor, it shouldn’t be the sole determinant.

Bernardo Brites, co-founder and CEO of Trace Finance, agrees, arguing that beyond market cap, a token’s track record and benchmark performance are crucial.

Brites explains, “Run any token through that list and the answer is short. Bitcoin passes clearly. Ether passes; everything else fails on track record or benchmark before a fiduciary ever gets to market cap.” He adds that the practical test lies in demonstrating a reliable, daily price from a regulated wrapper.

ETFs vs. Direct Crypto Holdings:

The Labor Department’s proposal does not restrict crypto investments to exchange-traded funds (ETFs) or managed funds. However, experts anticipate ETFs and managed funds will be offered first, due to their compatibility with existing custody and recordkeeping systems.

Direct crypto holdings could raise concerns about storage, cybersecurity, and pricing, according to Guillén. Yet, she stresses that these risks should not automatically exclude them.

Brites expects crypto investments to become available gradually, starting with existing brokerage options, followed by standalone ETFs and funds containing small amounts of crypto. He predicts some crypto investment options could emerge in 2027, with ETFs at larger employers later that year, and wider availability in retirement funds by 2028.

“The rule changes the legal risk, not the plumbing, and the plumbing is slower,” Brites concluded.

Leave a Reply