Are Alt-L1s Becoming Obsolete?
Security and cost concerns are driving smaller blockchains towards Ethereum. Zilliqa, Gnosis, and Ronin are the latest to join the Ethereum ecosystem, abandoning their independent Layer 1 (L1) architectures in favor of Ethereum-based Layer 2 (L2) solutions.
Running a standalone L1 offers control but comes with significant expenses. Blockchains require sufficient users, developers, and economic activity to support their security and infrastructure. For smaller networks, maintaining this becomes uneconomical.
Zilliqa, in a recent announcement, admitted that their nine-year attempt to sustain an independent L1 had been unsuccessful:
"Usage never reached what a standalone chain needs. Funding and liquidity dried up. The recent hacks highlighted the security challenges of a standalone chain."
They plan to transition to an Ethereum-based L2, as do other projects like Gnosis, through its Ethereum Economic Zone (EEZ) initiative, and Ronin, which completed its move to L2 in May.
The cost comparison is compelling:
- L1s need to maintain execution, consensus, data availability, and settlement, and fund token incentives for network security through staking.
- L2s, on the other hand, only require execution maintenance and can be more financially attractive.
According to Max Shannon, senior research analyst at Bitwise, the top ten largest projects are financially sustainable, with L2 networks like Coinbase and Robinhood generating substantial fees. However, smaller projects struggle to generate enough revenue.
Ethereum's revenue distribution has been criticized, but it is precisely this model that attracts projects to set up on the network.
Gnosis, aiming for a spring 2027 transition, will shift from its independent consensus to Ethereum settlement, showcasing the growing trend of smaller blockchains joining the Ethereum ecosystem.