Arthur Hayes on Coinbase's Support for Stock Perpetual Futures
Arthur Hayes expressed his sentiment, stating he was "flattered" by Coinbase's defense of US stock perpetual futures, a decade after BitMEX's introduction of perpetual swaps.
Arthur Hayes, BitMEX's co-founder, reflected on the contrasting reactions when BitMEX launched perpetual swaps in 2016. He noted, "When we launched the perpetual swap at BitMEX... Washington’s reaction was less than warm. Ten years later, Coinbase is in federal court defending the right to offer them on US stocks. I’m flattered. Imitation is the sincerest form of regulation."
Coinbase, along with five other companies, submitted a brief opposing the Capital Markets Alliance Association (CMAA)'s request to block trading in perpetual futures linked to individual stocks. The court accepted this brief on Tuesday.
CMAA argues that these contracts should be treated as security-based swaps, subject to stricter retail trading restrictions. Hayes, during his tenure as CEO of BitMEX, launched Bitcoin's perpetual swap, a product that contributed to perpetual swaps becoming a staple in crypto trading.
SEC and Stock Perpetuals
The US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) submitted a court brief on Monday, opposing CMAA's request to temporarily halt trading in these contracts. The SEC is reviewing the exchanges' rules for listing these contracts, leaving open whether they qualify as security futures or security-based swaps.
In a Tuesday court filing, CMAA claimed that the CFTC approved these contracts without sufficient explanation or addressing regulatory concerns. They also cited a significant 24-hour notional trading volume of approximately $375 million for Kalshi's stock perpetuals post-launch, suggesting these products were diverting business from traditional stock markets.
The Issue of Expiry
Stock perpetuals allow traders to speculate on individual share prices without owning the underlying stocks, lacking a fixed expiration date, unlike traditional futures.
On November 3rd, US District Judge Valerie Caproni denied CMAA's request for a temporary restraining order, as they hadn't demonstrated likely irreparable harm. She ruled that CMAA was likely to succeed in their claim that the CFTC exceeded its authority.
Wojciech Kaszycki, strategy adviser to BTCS SA, pointed out that the lack of a fixed expiration or delivery date might complicate the case for treating perpetual contracts as futures. He suggested that a ruling against the CFTC could drive trading activity to offshore and decentralized platforms. "The product doesn’t die; it just changes address."