Ethereum’s New DeFi Security Tool Raises Questions Over Censorship
Phylax’s system allows decentralized protocols to block potentially harmful transactions, but it raises questions about potential censorship and Ethereum’s concentrated builder market.
Phylax’s Security System for DeFi
Phylax’s new security system could help decentralized finance (DeFi) protocols stop malicious transactions before they settle, bolstering crypto’s defenses against North Korean hackers and sanctioned actors. However, it also introduces a method to freeze smart contract functions without explicit authorization. This has sparked concerns that the system could become a centralized tool for law enforcement rather than a decentralized finance solution.
“The question is not just whether there is risk, but if it’s acceptable risk,” says Stefanie Boss, co-author of research on censorship resistance and compliance behavior in Ethereum’s consensus mechanism. “In this case, I’d lean toward that it is acceptable, as the goal is to make the network safer and more aligned with the network and application values.”
Phylax’s Integration and Potential Risks
Announced on November 10, Phylax’s integration with block builder Titan Builder enables Ethereum applications to define rules that exclude harmful transactions during block construction. Titan, responsible for producing one in every two Ethereum blocks, checks transactions against these rules before including them. This aims to prevent exploits from settling, rather than relying on post-attack monitoring or interventions.
In a blog, Phylax uses the example of a vulnerable vault that could mistakenly release $1 million to a user with only $1,000 worth of shares. With the system in place, a circuit breaker could limit the amount leaving the vault in a single transaction, preventing a drain of funds. Similar measures could also mitigate losses in major hacks like the $6.3 billion Binance hack or the $380 million Bitget exploit.
Legal Concerns and Builder Concentration
While preventing malicious transactions is beneficial, digital assets lawyer Gabriel Shapiro warned that applications using the system could become effectively freezable if builders stop providing required attestations. Smart contracts can be configured to reject transactions unless they are included in blocks from builders who have performed security checks. If those builders cease attestations, protected functions could keep rejecting transactions until they resume.
Phylax founder and CEO Odysseas Lamtzidis suggests protocols can avoid this risk by allowing transactions to go through even when the system’s security checks are unavailable. However, he acknowledges that individual protocols may prioritize safety over availability, and they can also decide whether their smart contracts are immutable or changeable through governance.
Shapiro advocates for mandatory fail-open protections and time delays to prevent protocols from removing them immediately. There is also a broader concern about whether the system could reinforce Ethereum’s concentrated builder market, a problem that has previously caused issues in the ecosystem.